x

Skip to contentContribute to ReadWriteThink / RSS / FAQs / Site Demonstrations / Contact Us / About Us

 

 

Contribute to ReadWriteThink

ReadWriteThink couldn't publish all of this great content without literacy experts to write and review for us. If you've got lessons plans, videos, activities, or other ideas you'd like to contribute, we'd love to hear from you.

More

 

Professional Development

Find the latest in professional publications, learn new techniques and strategies, and find out how you can connect with other literacy professionals.

More

 

Did You Know?

Your students can save their work with Student Interactives.

More more


HomeClassroom ResourcesLesson Plans

Lesson Plan

For Argument's Sake: Playing "Devil's Advocate" with Nonfiction Texts

E-mail / Share / Print This Page / Print All Materials (Note: Handouts must be printed separately)

 

For Argument's Sake: Playing "Devil's Advocate" with Nonfiction Texts

Grades 9 – 12
Lesson Plan Type Standard Lesson
Estimated Time Four 90-minute sessions
Lesson Author

Jonathan Dorn

Jonathan Dorn

Greenville, South Carolina

Publisher

National Council of Teachers of English

 

Overview

Featured Resources

From Theory to Practice

 

OVERVIEW

In this lesson, students adopt the role of "devil's advocate" to debate a series of proposals to reform professional sports. By recognizing potential weaknesses in the proposals and considering the reforms from multiple perspectives, students exercise divergent thinking to inspire debate and achieve a comprehensive understanding of the issues. Using high-interest articles from The Atlantic magazine, students annotate the texts and respond to contentions by generating counterarguments. Students then debate the proposal to eliminate high school sports by representing the interests of stakeholders at a town hall meeting.

back to top

 

FEATURED RESOURCES

How to Play Devil’s Advocate:  This handout offers a number of ways for students to take an opposing viewpoint or raise an objection to a claim merely for the sake of argument

Town Hall Meeting Guide:  This handout explains the purpose and roles for debate structured around a town hall meeting format

back to top

 

FROM THEORY TO PRACTICE

In “Gateways to Writing Logical Arguments,” Thomas McMann argues that simply teaching students to write an argument is less effective than when students participate in “daily oral interchanges” in which students “[grapple] with problems and [respond] to the persistent questions of Why? So What? and Who says?” (34). McCann goes on to elaborate that when students “discuss an area of doubt, they require support for claims and they invite the consideration of competing arguments and multiple points of view” (34).

Role-playing “devil’s advocate” in a mock town hall meeting requires students to challenge the quality of a claim and assess whether the advantages outweigh the disadvantages of a proposal. By using the topic of sports, which appeals to a significant high school population, students are likely to find the issue relevant and the debate authentic.

McMann, Thomas. “Gateways to Writing Logical Arguments.” English Journal 99.6 (2010): 33-39. Web. 9 March 2014.

back to top